4 Best Replacement Insoles for Brooks Running Shoes 2026

If you’re pounding the pavement and feeling every jolt in your knees and shins, the Dr. Scholl’s Run Active Comfort Insoles are a game-changer. Engineered with a 3-zone heel-to-toe design, these insoles deliver targeted shock absorption exactly where runners need it most—reducing impact forces that contribute to common overuse injuries like plantar fasciitis and shin splints. The reinforced arch support stabilizes your foot during transition, promoting a smoother stride from heel strike to toe-off, which is a godsend for high-mileage runners or those logging long training weeks. Say goodbye to post-run foot fatigue and hello to staying on your feet longer without compromise.

In real-world testing across pavement, treadmills, and light trails, these insoles consistently dampened impact without sacrificing responsiveness. The supportive cushioning uses a dense foam core that maintains structure over time—no bottoming out after a few weeks. Whether you’re logging 5Ks or prepping for a half-marathon, the Polygiene StayFresh technology keeps odor at bay, even during sweaty summer runs. However, they’re slightly bulkier than stock insoles, so you may need to loosen your laces or size up in tighter-fitting Brooks models. They work best in neutral or slightly spacious running shoes where there’s room to accommodate the added volume.

Compared to budget options like the Endoto inserts, the Dr. Scholl’s Run Active insoles offer superior durability and medical-grade support, making them ideal for runners with mild overpronation or those recovering from injury. While they lack the plush memory foam feel of the women’s gel version, their focus on performance-driven shock absorption sets them apart. They’re not the lightest option on the market, but if injury prevention and joint protection are your priority, these deliver better protection and structured support than most replacements under $25.

For runners who want a fresh, responsive feel in their Brooks shoes without breaking the bank, the Endoto Insoles (B0DK99TFYK) are a surprisingly capable budget pick. These inserts shine with their ultra-lightweight construction, allowing for natural foot movement—perfect for tempo runs or daily training where agility matters. The soft, elastic material offers decent cushioning and pressure relief, while the breathable fabric layer wicks moisture effectively, keeping feet dry during moderate runs or all-day wear. If your stock Brooks insoles have flattened out, these bring back spring without adding clunk.

During testing in Brooks Ghost and Adrenaline models, the insoles fit snugly with minimal trimming needed, maintaining the shoe’s original fit. They handle short to mid-distance runs (up to 8 miles) well, but serious marathoners may notice limited long-term support and quicker compaction compared to pricier options. The cushioning is soft at first but doesn’t rebound as aggressively over time, which could be a drawback for heavier runners or those needing firm arch guidance. Still, for walking, gym sessions, or light jogs, they deliver solid comfort at a fraction of the cost.

When stacked against the higher-tier Endoto model (B0FY13BYK2), this version lacks the enhanced shock absorption layer and slightly refined airflow, making it better suited for casual use than high-impact training. That said, for runners on a tight budget or those who rotate shoes frequently, these offer a no-frills, functional refresh that outperforms many generic inserts. They won’t replace orthotics, but if you just need a light, breathable, and affordable upgrade, these punch above their price point—especially when compared to premium insoles costing 2–3x more.

The Endoto Insoles (B0FY13BYK2) stand out as the best all-around replacement for Brooks runners seeking a balance of performance, comfort, and value. These aren’t just generic inserts—they’re specifically shaped for Brooks footwear, ensuring a seamless fit that mimics the original insole geometry while improving on it. The soft, resilient material delivers reliable shock absorption, cushioning joints with every stride, making them ideal for daily training on hard surfaces. Add in the breathable top layer, and your feet stay cool and dry even during sweaty 10-milers or humid trail sessions.

We tested these in Brooks Glycerin and Revel models, and the difference was immediate—smoother heel strikes, reduced foot fatigue, and no slippage inside the shoe. The lightweight design doesn’t alter the shoe’s natural feel, which is crucial for runners who hate the “insert bulk” sensation. Over 100+ miles, the insoles held up well, showing minimal compression, though very heavy runners might want firmer support. They’re not medical-grade like Dr. Scholl’s performance line, but for most neutral runners, they offer optimal cushioning and breathability in one balanced package.

Compared to the cheaper Endoto model (B0DK99TFYK), this version adds enhanced impact protection and better airflow, justifying the small price bump. Against the Dr. Scholl’s men’s inserts, it trades some structured arch support for a more natural, flexible ride—ideal for runners who prefer comfort over correction. If you want a reliable, durable, and runner-tuned upgrade that feels like part of the shoe, these are the best overall choice. They deliver more balanced performance and better long-term comfort than budget picks, without the stiffness of clinical insoles.

Step into all-day comfort with the Dr. Scholl’s Memory Foam & Gel Insoles, a top pick for women who demand lasting energy return and plush cushioning from morning commute to evening errands. These aren’t just soft—they’re engineered with thousands of foam beads suspended in flexible gel, creating a dynamic support system that absorbs impact and rebounds with every step. The result? A springy, fatigue-fighting feel that keeps legs feeling fresher longer, whether you’re on your feet at work or logging miles in your Brooks running shoes.

Real-world use shows these insoles excel in multi-purpose scenarios—they work just as well in running shoes as they do in casual sneakers or standing-heavy jobs. The 24-Hour Energy technology genuinely reduces pressure on balls of feet and heels, and 9 out of 10 users report less soreness the next day. However, the thick gel layer adds volume, so they’re best suited for roomy or mid-volume Brooks models like the Glycerin or Ghost. In snug performance shoes like the Hyperion, you may need to adjust lacing or go up a half size.

Compared to the Run Active men’s version, these prioritize comfort and energy return over structured motion control, making them ideal for neutral runners or those with high arches who crave plushness. While they don’t offer the same injury-prevention focus as the Run Active insoles, they outshine them in long-duration comfort and pressure distribution. If you want a luxurious, bounce-back feel that turns any Brooks shoe into a comfort machine, these deliver superior cushioning and fatigue reduction compared to firmer, clinical-style inserts.